The Job Search Is Broken: Recruiting, AI, and Hiring Trends with Mitch McDermott (Ep. 101)

The Job Search Is Broken: Recruiting, AI, and Hiring Trends with Mitch McDermott (Ep. 101)

Author: Dustin Sutton December 19, 2025 Duration: 47:31

In this episode of Tools, Talents & Techniques, I sit down with Mitch McDermott, founder of Talent Ascension, to unpack what is really happening in today’s job market and why so many candidates and companies feel stuck.

Mitch shares his unconventional journey from the car business to building a successful executive search firm, including a bold move to Australia that reshaped his career and worldview. Along the way, we dig into how recruiting has evolved, how AI is changing hiring, and why automation has stripped too much humanity out of the process.

We talk about:

  • Why hiring has started to feel like dating apps
  • How generational shifts are changing expectations at work
  • The dangers of over-automating recruiting with AI
  • Why companies should hire for potential, not just resumes
  • How job seekers can stand out in a crowded, impersonal market
  • What it really means to connect with candidates on a human level

This conversation is especially relevant if you are a job seeker, founder, executive, recruiter, or leader trying to hire better people in a rapidly changing market.

Key Takeaways

  • Recruiting is about alignment, not just filling roles
  • Different industries require different hiring strategies
  • Hiring for potential matters more than checking boxes
  • Generational shifts accelerated after COVID
  • AI is powerful, but it can create unintended barriers
  • Mindset, resilience, and accountability drive long-term success
  • Relationships still beat algorithms in hiring

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to Mitch McDermott

02:17 From the Car Business to Australia

05:33 Breaking Into Executive Search

11:06 Recruitment Styles by Industry

13:48 Consulting Companies on Hiring Strategy

17:27 The Reverse Interview Process

20:34 Generational Shifts in the Job Market

22:29 In-Demand Skills Today

23:27 Changes in Sales Organizations

24:19 AI’s Role in Recruiting

27:51 Personal Growth and Inspiration

30:08 Mindset and Resiliency in Business

33:11 Accountability and Leadership

35:03 Books That Shape High Performers

38:41 Why the Job Search System Is Broken

41:16 Bringing Humanity Back to Hiring

Sound Bites

  • “The job search system is broken.”
  • “We lost the humanity in hiring.”
  • “Hiring feels like dating apps now.”

Connect with Mitch McDermott

🌐 Website https://www.talentascension.com/

🔗 LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/mitch-mcdermott-ba409387/

Follow Tools, Talents & Techniques

🌍 https://toolstalentstechniques.com

📺 https://youtube.com/@dustincsutton

📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/the3tpod/ X: https://twitter.com/the3tpod

Subscribe for weekly conversations with leaders, founders, innovators, and creatives across industries.

🎵 Music by C€$ https://open.spotify.com/artist/21zXwxV9nWaiE6iAleU6ww


Dustin Sutton hosts TOOLS TALENTS AND TECHNIQUES, a podcast built on the idea that success in any field is a blend of the right resources, innate abilities, and learned methods. The conversations here roam across a wide landscape, from the concrete strategies of real estate and business to the evolving dynamics of technology and the revealing parallels found in sports. Rather than offering quick tips, each episode settles into a detailed discussion with a genuine leader or innovator, unpacking the specifics of their path. You’ll hear how they’ve scaled ventures, managed personal evolution, and applied financial insights, all framed by their unique experiences. This isn't about abstract theory; it's about the tangible, often hard-won lessons that actually move the needle. The result is a collection of dialogues that feel both broad in scope and deeply practical, whether you're building a company, honing a skill, or simply curious about the mechanics of achievement. Tune into this podcast for those unscripted moments where real strategy and personal insight intersect, providing a useful perspective no matter your own professional arena.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

TOOLS TALENTS AND TECHNIQUES with Dustin Sutton
Podcast Episodes
FREEWYLD Founder and Entrepreneur Eric Moeller (Ep.68) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:20
FREEWYLD Founder and Entrepreneur Eric MoellerIn this episode, Dustin Sutton interviews Eric Moeller, the founder of FreeWyld, a cabin experiential company located in Idyllwild, California. Eric shares his journey from a…
Tyrome 'Ty' Smith - Putting People in Scoring Position (Ep. 67) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:59
In this episode, Tyrome ('Ty') Smith shares his journey from a small-town upbringing in Pennsylvania to a successful career supporting the intelligence community and working with startups. He discusses the importance of…
Tonya Torosian - CEO Promises2Kids (Ep. 63) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:02
In this episode, Tonya Torosian, CEO of Promises2Kids, shares her journey from a community-focused upbringing in Wisconsin to leading a nonprofit dedicated to supporting foster youth in San Diego.She discusses the import…
Ep. 62: Dan Engel - Founder of Miracle League of San Diego [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:02:31
In this conversation, Dan Engel shares his remarkable journey from a successful investment banker to a dedicated nonprofit leader after battling stage four melanoma. He discusses the importance of giving back, the creati…
Sunday Golf featuring Ronan Galvin and Patrick Courtney (Ep. 61) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:42
In this conversation, the founders and key members of Sunday Golf share their journey of creating a unique golf bag company. They discuss the origins of their product, the challenges faced during the COVID-19 pandemic, a…
Stephen Daniel Clarke - Global Executive Director at JLL (Ep. 60) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:32
Stephen Clarke brings a wealth of knowledge and experience from over two decades in strategy, governance, innovation, engagement, and leadership development. Currently, he serves as a Global Executive Director at JLL, fo…
Chris Chiari - The Vision Behind The 420 Hotels (Ep. 59) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:12
Chris Chiari - Founder/CEO at The 420 HotelsIn this conversation, Chris Chiari shares his journey from a childhood in New Jersey to becoming the founder of the 420 Hotels in Denver, a unique cannabis hospitality venture.…