Rise And Fall Of A Pro Pitcher: From the Bull Pen To The Texas Pen

Rise And Fall Of A Pro Pitcher: From the Bull Pen To The Texas Pen

Author: Robert Riggs June 26, 2023 Duration: 38:58

The high school baseball player hung a homemade motivational sign on the wall of his bedroom.  It read Brandon Puffer will be a Major League Baseball player.

Indeed, Puffer made it to what ballplayers call “The Show.” 

Only to fall from the Bullpen to the State Penitentiary in Texas.

Brandon Puffer was a pitcher on the Boston Red Sox baseball team when they broke a century-old curse and won the World Series in 2004.

But four years later, a Texas jury sentenced Puffer to five years in prison.

He survived the tough Texas prison system and is now out.

Puffer has written a book titled, From The Bullpen To The State Pen, in which he opens up about his experience.

In this episode of True Crime Reporter®, Puffer shares the story of his setbacks and come back.


Puffer coaches youth and high school baseball players on how to play college and pro ball at GPSLegends, located in Central Texas near Round Rock and Georgetown.


In closing, here’s my reporter’s recap and reflections.

No matter what walk of life they came from, most of the convicted felons that I have interviewed did not comprehend that their actions had consequences.

To quote Puffer, “the longer we try to ignore or run from those consequences, the more they will grow like a cancer that starts small, but eventually takes over the whole body if ignored. 

You’ve been listening to the True Crime Reporter Podcast: Stay True. Stay Safe. And Stay Tuned for more stories from inside the crime scene tape.

This is Robert Riggs Reporting.


Insightful Quotes From Brandon Puffer in From The Bullpen To The State Pen:

One of the devil’s schemes is to make you think the only one who thinks a certain way or acts the way you do–it’s a feeling of isolation, and when humans feel isolated, the mind has a tendency to go to some dark places.

Our actions in this life have consequences, and the longer we try to ignore or run from those consequences, the more they will grow–like a cancer that starts small, but eventually takes over the whole body if ignored.

The music we listen to, the things we watch, the games we play, and the words we speak…they all take a toll over time, and only you have the power to control what enters your mind and soul. 

You have the power to make choices before the choices that will define you.

My dream was derailed by one decision that was actually many smaller decisions that led up to that moment.


FOLLOW the True Crime Reporter® Podcast 

SIGN UP FOR my True Crime Newsletter

THANK YOU FOR THE FIVE-STAR REVIEWS ON APPLE Please leave one – it really helps.

TELL ME about a STORY OR SUBJECT  that you want to hear more about


Robert Riggs has spent decades as an investigative reporter, and in True Crime Reporter, he applies that relentless, document-driven approach to the stories that haunt us. This isn't just a retelling of grim headlines; it's a meticulous walk through active case files, historical injustices, and the societal undercurrents that allow crime to flourish. Each episode feels like you're sitting across from Riggs as he lays out his notes, connecting dots between evidence, witness accounts, and the often-overlooked details that change a narrative. You'll hear the tension in the pursuit of truth, the weight of unresolved questions, and the quiet impact on communities and families left in the wake of violence. The podcast moves beyond the sensational to examine the cultural and systemic factors at play, offering a sober, deeply researched perspective. Listen for long-form narratives that build like a detective's board, where every piece of audio, every interview, and every document serves a purpose. It’s for those who want to understand the 'why' and the 'how' as much as the 'who,' presented with the clarity and authority of a seasoned journalist who knows the terrain. This is a journey into real stories, handled with the care they demand, and it naturally becomes an essential listen for anyone fascinated by the intersection of human behavior, justice, and the news.
Author: Language: en-us Episodes: 100

True Crime Reporter
Podcast Episodes
Brotherhood of Brutality Unchecked Fraternity Hazing [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:19
By Robert Riggs Burned with lit cigarettes. Impaled with a fishhook. Staples fired into his hip. Deadly drugs forced up his nose. It sounds like a brutal regime’s methods from a torture chamber. But these are the homegro…
JigSaw & Jane 13 Years of Murder & Mayhem with Badge Number One [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:23
By Robert Riggs LAPD Homicide Detective John St. John aka “JigSaw John” Badge #1 Legendary LAPD Homicide Detective John St. John walked among the dead for nearly a half-century. Known as “JigSaw John,” he pursued monster…
Don’t Make It Easy for a Violent Predator to Choose You [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 19:41
Most predators don’t pounce—they pick. They observe. They wait. And they choose the person who looks the easiest to catch. In this episode, you’ll learn how to make sure you’re not the one they choose. From FBI profilers…
Women Who Talk To The Dead [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:34
The Story of 200 Forgotten Murder Victims By Robert Riggs They were daughters. Mothers. Sisters. Strangers. Their lives ended violently—and their names were lost to time. For more than half a century, Detroit’s forgotten…
Widow Offers One Million Dollars To Crack Cold Case Murder Mystery [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:32
Unsolved Murder of Jim Grimes Haunts Quiet Tennessee Town By Robert Riggs A bold reward offers ONE MILLION DOLLARS to solve a cold case murder mystery. Since the $25 million bounty on Osama bin Laden, few rewards have re…
The Rock: Alcatraz’s Chilling True Crime Legacy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:49
Alcatraz shut its cell doors more than 60 years ago, but its grip on the American imagination hasn’t loosened. Each year, nearly a million and a half tourists ride the ferry across San Francisco Bay, through cold, choppy…
The Click That Opens The Door To Cyber Hell [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 34:46
You Just Thought Your Home Was Safe By Robert Riggs You lock your doors at night. You check on your kids. But what if the real threat is already inside—hiding in your phone, your smart TV, or your child’s video game chat…
Why Do Women Love True Crime? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:34
A Former 48 Hours Producer Reveals the Psychology and Power Behind the Genre By Robert Riggs When the curtain drops on everyday life, true crime shows like this podcast and especially those on television expose the darke…