Missing 5-Year-Old Hayden Manis | Unreported for FIVE YEARS • Part 1

Missing 5-Year-Old Hayden Manis | Unreported for FIVE YEARS • Part 1

Author: True Crime Society September 25, 2025 Duration: 46:52
Timestamps:
(10:06) - D4VD
(15:30) - Hayden Manis

It is a story that we now hear all too often.   A child is missing for years before anyone notices and reports it to authorities.  We have covered many cases like this in the past - Harmony Montgomery and Oakley Carlson to name but two.

Hayden Manis is also one of these children.  
Hayden was around five years old when he went missing from  his home in Muncie, Indiana in either 2019 or 2020 (stories differ).  He was not reported missing for four to five years.

Hayden’s extended family realized that he was missing in 2024.  When Hayden’s father Dustin was questioned about his son’s whereabouts, he gave conflicting stories.  Dustin died in December 2024 from a drug overdose and left no clue as to what happened to Hayden.

In this episode of the True Crime Society Podcast, we tell part one of Hayden Manis’ story.  We run through the background of the case and the early stages of the investigation into Hayden’s disappearance.

Read our blog for Hayden

Join us next week for Part Two as we discuss what has happened in the investigation to date.

This episode is sponsored by:
  • Quince - Keep it classic and cozy this fall cool—with long-lasting staples from Quince. Go to Quince.com/tcs for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. 
Be sure to follow us on all social media including Reddit and Tiktok - just search ‘True Crime Society’ 

Join our Patreon community for weekly exclusive content and all episodes are ad-free - Patreon.com/truecrimesociety



There's a particular chill that runs down your spine when a story feels too close to home, when the details of a case ripple out and touch the ordinary world we all inhabit. True Crime Society, hosted by the team at True Crime Society, digs into that exact space where shocking crimes intersect with our everyday social and cultural fabric. This isn't just a chronological retelling of grim events; it's an exploration of the communities left in the wake of tragedy, the societal conditions that allow certain stories to unfold, and the cultural obsessions that turn real-life pain into public narrative. Each episode carefully examines how a crime influenced, or was influenced by, the world around it-from media frenzies and legal shifts to neighborhood gossip and lasting urban legends. You'll hear deep dives into cases that changed laws, defined decades, or exposed hidden fractures in our systems, all discussed with a focus on context and consequence rather than sheer sensation. Tune into this podcast for a thoughtful, layered perspective that asks not only "what happened," but "why did it happen here, to these people, and what does that tell us about ourselves?" It's for anyone who feels true crime is more than a guilty pleasure-it's a lens on society itself.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

True Crime Society
Podcast Episodes
(RE-RELEASE) Hell on Wheels | Mackenzie Shirilla [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:05:16
In this episode of the True Crime Society Podcast, we discuss the case of Mackenzie Shirilla. We also discuss creepy updates in the case of the BTK serial killer. Police have released sketches done by Dennis Rader and ha…