Jasper Hoffman, Part 2 - Undercover Therapy, Leaving the Mennonites, and the Aftermath

Jasper Hoffman, Part 2 - Undercover Therapy, Leaving the Mennonites, and the Aftermath

Author: Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts July 15, 2026 Duration: 50:18

This week, the girls are back with Jasper Hoffman, writer, podcaster, and former Mennonite. In part two today, Jasper explains what the perfect Mennonite woman looked like, how concerns were raised when she wasn't compliant enough, and how over time she became depressed and developed an eating disorder in response to the pressures of the group.

She’ll share how her mom secretly found her a therapist on the outside, even though it was against the rules, and how that therapist helped her write a letter to withdraw her membership, which led to the harassment of her family. We’ll talk about how she tried to go back after she left but realized she really didn’t belong, and why she started the Plain People’s Podcast.

SOURCES

The Plain People's Podcast

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.


There's a particular chill that runs down your spine when you realize how easily a persuasive idea can cross into dangerous territory. Trust Me: Cults, Extreme Belief, and Manipulation explores that unsettling frontier, not from a distant, academic view, but from the inside out. Each week, hosts Lola Blanc and Meagan Elizabeth guide conversations with a unique and critical perspective-they've both navigated the complex journey out of cults themselves. This shared experience fosters a rare depth of understanding in their interviews. You'll hear directly from survivors of groups ranging from the infamous Manson Family and Heaven's Gate to more contemporary organizations like NXIVM and OneTaste. These aren't just historical accounts; they are intimate, personal narratives detailing the specific moments of attraction, the gradual process of indoctrination, and the often tumultuous path to reclaiming one's own mind. The podcast, produced by Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts, sits at a compelling intersection of society, culture, and true crime, occasionally finding moments of unexpected comedy in the absurdities of extreme belief systems. It’s a weekly examination of the human need for belonging, the mechanisms of control, and the resilient stories of those who found their way back. Listening feels like being part of a crucial, compassionate conversation about the lines we all navigate between faith and fanaticism, community and coercion.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Trust Me: Cults, Extreme Belief, and Manipulation
Podcast Episodes
John Hunter - Manufacturing Mania in Self-Help Seminars [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:10:48
This week’s guest is psychology researcher and lecturer Dr. John Hunter, joining the show to talk about intensive self-help seminars–known as “large group awareness trainings,” or LGATs–and the emotions they produce. He…
Laci Mosley – Scams vs. Cults, and the Many Forms of Fraud [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:14:37
This week, the girls are joined by Laci Mosley, comedian, actress, and host of the Scam Goddess podcast and TV show (and author of Scam Goddess the book), to talk about the many types of frauds that are out there, from r…
Anke Richter, Part 2 - Harem Culture, Leaving ISTA, and DeCult [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:05
This week is part 2 with Anke Richter, journalist, author of Cult Trip, former member of Tantric group ISTA, and founder and director of New Zealand’s cult conference DeCult. In part 2 with Anke, she explains how the fou…
Anke Richter, Part 1 - Ecstatic Dancing, Tantric Sex, and Joining ISTA [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:05
Today is part 1 with Anke Richter, journalist, author of Cult Trip, former member of Tantric group International School of Temple Arts, and founder and director of New Zealand’s cult conference DeCult. In this week’s epi…
Jasper Hoffman, Part 1 - From Atheists to Mennonites [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:26
This week, the girls are joined by Jasper Hoffman, writer, podcaster, and former Mennonite. In part one, she explains how her parents went from a being punk rock atheist and an anthropology major to homesteading, homesch…