Terrifying & True | Alfred Packer: The Colorado Cannibal’s 1874 Murder Trial

Terrifying & True | Alfred Packer: The Colorado Cannibal’s 1874 Murder Trial

Author: Henrique Couto | Scary Stories & Horror Expert January 12, 2026 Duration: 45:46
A blizzard. A vanished trail. The San Juan Mountains in the winter of 1874. Six men leave safety behind—and only one walks back into town. This is the infamous Alfred (Alferd) Packer story: the “Colorado Cannibal” case that refuses to stay settled, because the evidence is brutal… and the survivor’s account keeps shifting.

In this episode of Terrifying & True, we follow the doomed decision to cross the high country after Chief Ouray’s warning, the slow collapse into starvation, and the moment the frontier stops being romantic and becomes a cold, clinical math problem: move or die. Then comes the part that turned suspicion into fury—Packer returning alive, armed, spending money, and carrying other men’s belongings, offering explanations that mutate under pressure.

And when the thaw gives up what the snow hid—five bodies, skulls split by a hatchet, butchered remains on a slope near Lake City—the story transforms from survival horror into a courtroom nightmare: confessions, escape, a retrial, a legal technicality, and a sentence that changes… even as the legend hardens.
Inside this episode:
  • The last “clean moment”: Chief Ouray’s warning—and why it didn’t stop them
  • The six who left: the men, the reputations, and the stakes that followed them into the snow
  • Starvation’s escalation: boots, leather, and the point where “survival” becomes something else
  • Dead Man’s Gulch: the gap between what we can prove and what one man claims
  • The changing story: why Packer’s versions keep reshaping themselves
  • The discovery in the thaw: what the scene says when words can’t be trusted
  • Trial, technicality, and legend: how the case becomes folklore without ever becoming clear

Because in the end, the wilderness doesn’t need ghosts to be haunted. Sometimes it only needs snow thick enough to erase tracks… and one man left alive to explain what happened. We’re telling that story tonight.

🎧 LISTEN NOW and subscribe for spine-tingling horror stories every week!

🎉 Unlock exclusive bonus episodes and support the show on Patreon!
👉 WeeklySpooky.com/Join

📬 Contact Us / Submit Your Horror Story!

🎵 Music by Ray Mattis 👉 Check out Ray’s incredible work here !
👨‍💼 Executive Producers: Rob Fields, Bobbletopia.com
🎥 Produced by: Daniel Wilder
🌐 Explore more terrifying tales at: WeeklySpooky.com

Henrique Couto has spent years digging into the shadows, and in Weekly Spooky: Horror Stories & Scary Tales, he turns that expertise into a regular dose of dread. This isn't just a seasonal treat; it's a year-round exploration of the unsettling, released every Monday and Wednesday. You'll hear original tales woven from classic threads-the whisper of an urban legend, the creak of a haunted house floorboard, the grim history of a cursed object. Familiar monsters like vampires and werewolves get fresh, chilling life, while cryptids lurk in the margins of modern myths. Each story is crafted for a mature audience, blending dark humor with genuinely cinematic sound design that pulls you right into the scene, all leading to those satisfying, often shocking, twist endings. While the podcast naturally excels during the spooky season with special deep dives, the commitment to weekly frights means the atmosphere is always ripe for a scare, whether the subject is pure fiction, dramatic re-tellings, or tales ripped from true crime's darkest corners. Settle in for a journey where the familiar becomes frightening again, narrated by a guide who truly understands the mechanics of a good, lasting chill.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Weekly Spooky: Horror Stories & Scary Tales
Podcast Episodes
BANNED! Part 4: Blizzard Horror Convention Slasher Finale [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 51:40
Winter slasher horror, murder mystery, and survival terror collide in the final chapter of BANNED! as the High Point Ski Lodge disappears under a relentless blizzard and the Horror Snow-In reaches its breaking point.With…
Monthly Spooky | Haunted Castles & Stolen Corpses [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:21:13
Haunted castles, ghost stories, eerie history, and true crime weirdness—this month’s Monthly Spooky with Henrique & Michelle goes full winter-night mode with paranormal legends, unsettling discoveries, and a real-life di…
Best of 2025: Deadly Second Chances - Supernatural Horror Story Binge [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 4:08:10
A Best of 2025 fan-favorite returns in one killer collection: Deadly Second Chances—the summer mini-series that drops you into the Strickfield universe where second chances come with teeth.In Perdition, the Hellweaver di…
BANNED! Part 3: The Killer Goes Public! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:54
Slasher horror, murder mystery, and winter survival terror collide as the Horror Snow-In at High Point Ski Lodge continues under a tightening blizzard lockdown—and the killer behind BANNED stops treating this like a secr…