221. Identity Based vs. Skill Based Mentoring // Mentoring Minute

221. Identity Based vs. Skill Based Mentoring // Mentoring Minute

Author: Zach Garza & You Can Mentor: Faith-Based Mentoring for Churches, Non-Profits, Youth Ministers, and Teachers February 22, 2024 Duration: 8:42

Identity-Based vs. Skill-Based Mentoring


“Just like a good tool doesn’t make you a handy man. Knowing skills alone doesn’t fulfill your mentee’s potential” 


Skill-based mentoring usually goes like this: 

  • Think of things you think your mentee should know
    • Shake a hand, tie a tie, resume, etc…
  • Teach them these things
  • Hope they use them to reach their full-potential

--

Skill-based mentoring is good, but I believe it is secondary to Identity-based mentoring


Skills are no good if you’re mentee believes:

  • They lack intelligence or can't succeed
  • They will never amount to anything
  • They lack confidence, hope or have no self-value

--


Let’s start with identity-based mentoring first.

  • Help them see themselves how God sees them. 
  • Encourage, build up, & champion your mentee
  • Be the most encouraging person in the world

--

When they believe this, they will have intrinsic motivation to learn the skills. They will be hungry to become all that they can be because they believe in themselves and have someone believing in them. 


Now that they believe they have worth and are capable of success, introduce the skills. 


First identity. Then skills.

--

Please follow @youcanmentor on social media and give us a 5 star rating! If you are a part of a mentoring organization, we'd love to get to know you! Please reach out to us and we can spotlight your org on the pod or on our website. 
Contact us at zach@youcanmentor.com or at www.youcanmentor.com.


Hosted by Zach Garza, You Can Mentor: A Christian Youth Mentoring Podcast is a conversation for anyone guiding young people within a faith context. This isn't about abstract theory; it's a practical resource built for the real challenges faced by youth ministers, church volunteers, teachers, and parents. Each episode focuses on the tangible aspects of building relationships that matter, offering grounded advice on how to listen, encourage, and walk alongside the next generation. The core of this podcast is a shared belief that effective mentoring flows from a foundation of loving God and loving others, aiming to make disciples right where you live. We delve into the questions you actually have, because your input directly shapes the discussions. Many episodes are crafted from real questions submitted by listeners, making the content immediately relevant to your own mentoring relationships. Whether you're navigating a difficult conversation, seeking creative ways to connect, or looking to sustain your own spiritual health while pouring into others, this space is designed to equip and encourage you. The goal is to see Christian mentors not just manage, but truly thrive in their vital roles. Tune in for honest stories, actionable strategies, and a sense of community, all aimed at helping you cultivate a more meaningful and impactful mentoring practice.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

You Can Mentor: A Christian Youth Mentoring Podcast
Podcast Episodes
210. Why I Mentor with De'Onte Garrett from Mentoring Alliance [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 32:27
Every mentor has a different story. They come from different backgrounds, experience different things in life, and can bring unique elements to the table in a mentoring relationship. The organization they get plugged int…
204. Is Mentoring Discipleship? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:14
If you look in the Bible, there isn't one mention of the word "mentor". However, you can find the word "discipleship" all over the place. As Christians, we're called to "go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing th…