September Seasonality in Midterm Years | High Alert Heading into September | Deficits vs Tax Rates | Mega Cap Winners and Losers | Forward P/E Check Dispersion

September Seasonality in Midterm Years | High Alert Heading into September | Deficits vs Tax Rates | Mega Cap Winners and Losers | Forward P/E Check Dispersion

Author: Derek Moore September 1, 2026 Duration: 57:47

Derek Moore and Shane Skinner dig into what history says about September in a midterm election year, and why Mike Santoli argues investors should be on high alert heading into the month. Plus, a long look at federal receipts versus federal outlays as a percent of GDP and what top tax rates did and did not do to revenue, the widening spread between mega cap winners and losers in 2026, and a forward earnings check on Nvidia, Alphabet, Apple, Tesla, Costco, and the S&P 500 itself. All that and more this week.

 

 

S&P 500 September performance in midterm election years going back to 1928.

September is historically the weakest month, but midterm years have their own pattern.

Mike Santoli argues investors should be on high alert heading into September.

What being on high alert actually means for someone already invested and hedged.

Federal receipts and federal net outlays as a percent of GDP going back to the 1930s.

Outlays keep running above receipts, and that gap is where the deficit comes from.

The top individual income tax bracket has fallen from over 90% since the 1940s.

Higher top tax rates have not reliably produced higher receipts as a share of GDP.

Schwab data ranks 2026 performance and index contribution across the mega caps.

Micron leads the group up 226.8% while Tesla is down 22.5% as of August 28, 2026.

Apple at 17.6%, Nvidia at 16.6%, and Amazon at 15.4% beat the Nasdaq's 13.6%.

Meta is down 12.4% and sits near the bottom on contribution to the S&P 500.

Nvidia trades near 17 times forward earnings on estimates of $12.83 a share.

Alphabet sits near 19 times forward earnings versus Apple at over 33 times.

Tesla's forward P/E is above 180 while Costco holds near 41 times.

The S&P 500 near 7,689 on forward earnings estimates of about $394 a share.

That works out to roughly 19.4 times forward earnings for the index.

SpaceX vs Tesla forward price to earnings ratio

Are index level multiples reasonable when the leadership is this uneven?

 

Mentioned in this Episode

 

Santoli: Why investors should be on high alert heading into September https://www.cnbc.com/2026/08/31/santoli-why-investors-should-be-on-high-alert-heading-into-september.html

 

Derek Moore's book Broken Pie Chart https://amzn.to/3S8ADNT

 

Jay Pestrichelli's book Buy and Hedge https://amzn.to/3jQYgMt

 

Derek's book on public speaking Effortless Public Speaking https://amzn.to/3hL1Mag

 

Contact Derek derek.moore@zegainvestments.com


Derek Moore hosts Broken Pie Chart, a podcast that digs into the practical realities of managing money in a complex world. The name comes from the idea that traditional, rigid models for investing and planning often don't reflect real life. Each episode takes a specific concept-whether it's portfolio construction, market behavior, or preparing for retirement-and breaks it down into straightforward conversation. You'll hear clear explanations of economic trends and financial principles without the jargon, focusing on how these ideas actually impact personal and professional decisions. This isn't about hot stock tips; it's about building a durable understanding of how markets and the economy function. The goal is to provide listeners with a stronger foundation for their own financial choices, making seemingly opaque topics accessible and relevant. Tune in for a thoughtful, grounded perspective that challenges conventional wisdom and simplifies the complicated.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Broken Pie Chart
Podcast Episodes
INTC vs NVDA | Prediction Markets Scam | Mag 7 Big Earnings Week [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:00:08
Derek Moore is joined by Mike Snyder and Shane Skinner to talk about semiconductors and the relative surprising performance of Intel vs Nvidia. Plus, they examine forward PE ratios and how stocks making new all-time high…