Episode #2.7 - I Died For Love

Episode #2.7 - I Died For Love

Author: Olivia Harding July 31, 2025 Duration: 30:40

This episode of Folk Files looks at a family of songs where the main character "dies for love." In particular, I explore "The Butcher Boy," a song with American, Irish, and English versions. The versions vary drastically: they swap out characters, drop details, and change the reasoning behind the narrator's decisions. I investigate what effect these changes have on the listener and what lessons we can draw from those effects.

Host: Olivia Harding

Check out more from Pollyanna: https://open.spotify.com/artist/1Rgyvnw9WrAm20MhlS2kyp?si=irIKZtNOTFaZWDOt9mh0cA

Special thanks to: Aaron J. Morton

Support Folk Files: https://www.patreon.com/c/FolkFilesPodcast

*This episode of Folk Files was recorded on the road. Apologies for any lapses in quality.*


Musical excerpts:

ARTIST: Alisa Marie

WORK: O'Carolan's Cup

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/zrBwqFco0Xs?si=-SdsYnEWGiD5SnFO


ARTIST: Sarah Makem

WORK: The Butcher Boy

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/x_mtUaBHWCE?si=tBXVy9ELCV9dECgh


ARTIST: Derek and Hazel Sarjeant

WORK: A Sailor Coming Home on Leave

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/e91Ug-CAjAc?si=sMcd-NpQC-FQmNSL


ARTIST: Music the Gathering

WORK: Johnny Jump Up

SOURCE: https://www.musicthegathering.com/store/lvl-3-digital-album-esexe


ARTIST: Frank Profitt

WORK: Morning Fair

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/wdyO1890Zpc?si=1esdsYhrRNWTg7zD


ARTIST: Sam Lee

WORK: Over Yonders Hill

SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2jcdbFRRYc


ARTIST: The Kings of Calicutt

WORK: Sheffield Park

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/o1lDKhJd6Pw?si=XWyn9hQQ3ImN2PRq


ARTIST: Bellowhead

WORK: Cold Blows the Wind

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WvuxL8UQiLQ?si=Sdr7Zz7yUVEXi7zg


ARTIST: Jean Ritchie

WORK: Go Dig My Grave

SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGrcOqcbzYk


ARTIST: The Clancy Brothers

WORK: The Butcher Boy

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WMc8QSxZe_M?si=PIv8GZyRL_1vkSRD


ARTIST: Buell Kazee

WORK: Butcher's Boy

SOURCE: https://youtu.be/lwSJoMNRGuI?si=fehdH-zflcTkTbY2


ARTIST: Pollyanna

WORK: Railroad Boy

SOURCE: https://pollyanna.bandcamp.com/album/man-time-deluxe-edition


Olivia Harding hosts Folk Files, a podcast that feels like rummaging through a dusty, fascinating archive. Each episode picks up a thread from the vast tapestry of folk music, following it through time to see where it leads. You’ll hear the stories behind the songs-not just the polished versions, but the raw, often complicated histories that birthed them. The focus is on the music that people carried with them, the tunes that survived because they held some essential truth, a warning, or a collective memory. This means digging into the origins of haunting murder ballads, the rhythmic work songs of sailors, and anthems born from defiance. The podcast is less about definitive answers and more about exploration, connecting the dots between a melody’s past and its lingering presence. It’s for anyone who has ever heard an old tune and wondered about the hands that first played it or the events that etched it into tradition. Listening to this podcast, you become part of a conversation across generations, understanding how a sea shanty’s call-and-response mirrored life on a ship, or how a rebel song’s lyrics were adapted and adopted by different struggles. Harding guides these journeys with a researcher’s curiosity and a genuine appreciation for the material, letting the music and its history speak for themselves. The result is a series that treats folk music not as a relic but as a living, breathing record of human experience, full of mysteries waiting to be gently uncovered one episode at a time.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 32

Folk Files
Podcast Episodes
Episode #3.5 - Rise Again [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 22:02
Stan Rogers was one of Canada's greatest singer-songwriters, despite his music having never had major distribution or significant radio playtime. In this episode, I discuss the (tragically short) life of the impressive b…
Episode #3.4 - There Were Two Sisters [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:21
A harrowing murder ballad in which an older sister shoves her younger sister in the water (and sometimes a musician makes an instrument from the drowned girl's corpse) can be found all over Great Britain, North America,…
Episode #3.3 - The Music of Temple Bar [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:50
In this St. Patrick's Day episode, I ask the question: Is it actually Irish? We will explore over thirty songs that are performed in Irish contexts and see if they actually come from Irish sources. Along the way, we'll d…
Episode #3.2 - He Never Returned [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 27:00
Is "The MTA Song" a conservative song or a communist song (or neither)? And why did record companies try to hide the origins of the tune of one of the most prolific early 20th century country songs? Find out in this epis…
Episode #3.1 - Piping in the Haggis [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 26:55
Welcome to the third season of Folk Files! We are starting off the year with a Robert Burns-themed episode to celebrate Burns Night on January 25th. Learn about the traditions associated with the Burns Night Supper and d…
Episode #2.12 - Lully, Lulla [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 25:21
Happy Holidays! Coventry Carol is a lullaby to a "little tiny child"...but surprisingly, that child is not Jesus. Learn more about this Christmas carol that was almost lost to time, including the history of modern Wester…
Bonus Episode: The Ballad World of Anna Gordon [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:13
In this bonus episode of Folk Files, I interview Ruth Perry, the author of The Ballad World of Anna Gordon, Mrs. Brown of Falkland. Anna Gordon is one of the most famous source singers in the history of folk music from t…
Episode #2.11 - The Flower of England [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 26:43
For a long time, "The Death of Queen Jane" has been considered a folk song that takes artistic liberties with the historic event of the birth of Edward VI to Jane Seymour in 1537. But is it possible that the song hints a…
Folk Files #2.10 - Beware the Moss [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 23:14
Long Lankin is the bogeyman of the Child Ballads. A mysterious figure who lives in the moss (or the gorse, or the hay), he is known as a bloodthirsty murderer. But what's the full story? Explore the origins of the horror…
Folk Files #2.9 - I Said the Sparrow [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 32:53
Who Killed Cock Robin? It was I, said the Sparrow. But where did the song come from? And what does it mean? Explore a world of birds, nursery rhymes, mythology, and history in this month's episode. Host: Olivia Harding S…