It Chapter Two Review

It Chapter Two Review

Author: Horror Movie Talk: Horror Movie Review September 11, 2019 Duration: 1:34:07

We saw It Chapter Two, and I have to say, I can make plenty of criticisms about this movie, but on the whole, this is a well done ending to a high budget franchise that has delivered the scares.

It Chapter Two movie poster

It Chapter Two Trailer

https://youtu.be/xhJ5P7Up3jA

It Chapter Two full movie is available to pre-purchase and rental on Amazon, and probably other places

It Chapter Two

Watch the full movie of It Chapter Two

It Chapter Two Synopsis

If you would like to be reminded of the first chapter of this series which is also directed by Andy Muschietti, check out our review from last week, where we go over the whole first chapter. It Chapter Two picks up 27 years later and details the lives of the kids turned adults from the first movie. As a quick recap, our character list is:

  • Bev – The girl in the group played by Jessica Chastain
  • Ben – The fat boy/new kid turned CEO hunk played by Jay Ryan
  • Bill – Stutterer turned author played by James McAvoy
  • Rich – Biting wit who wears glasses turned Comedian played by  Bill Hader
  • Mike – Token black kid who stayed in Derry played by Isaiah Mustafa
  • Eddie – Munchausen by proxy kid turned Munchausen by proxy adult played by James Ransone
  • Stan – Feeble Jewish kid turned feeble Jewish adult played by Andy Bean
Most of the adult cast of It Chapter Two
Mike, Rich, Bill, Bev, and Ben, but no Eddie…

Mike, has begun to notice nefarious happenings in Derry and as you
might guess, it’s been 27 years since the Loser’s Club made their pact to fight
It if it ever came back. Mike sends the call out to all of his long-lost
friends, and they respond with dread, but come home anyway. 

Check out Our Review of It (2017)

https://www.horrormovietalk.com/2019/09/04/it-2017-review/

The Loser’s Club has a cloud of forgetfulness that has descended
upon them in the time since their Derry days, and Mike, being the only member
to stay in Derry has to help them recall what happened and how they can beat
it.

As the Loser’s Club sets out on Derry, they are reminded of the
reason they left, the clown, the fear, and the life they left behind.

It Chapter Two Movie Review

It Chapter Two is similar enough to the first movie that you can rely on many of the same things that worked. The intense subject matter, your mom jokes, and the camaraderie are all there. We even get the kids cast back for a bounty of flashbacks and memories. It also has a hefty bag of very effective scares, that are less frequent, but more potent.

Pennywise the clown offering a helping hand
“How about a hand?!” No thanks PW…

Where It Chapter Two differs is the length and interesting subject matter. At 2h 49min, It Chapter Two is more than a half-hour longer than the first entry. I’ve never been a fan of long movies because at the 2h 30min mark I just feel like any reasonable story can fit everything and the kitchen sink in there. My mind wandered multiple times through the emotion-driven dialog, and it was a bit boring.

I wasn’t a big fan of the action-laden ending either. That being
said, this is a solid horror movie that may be one of the most successful franchises
ever, and it’s not without good reason. The cast, acting, direction, and story
are great. There is fun to be had, and the scares are for real. I wish they
kept it tighter.

Score for It Chapter Two Movie

8/10

Spoilers for It Chapter Two

Introduction to Our Adult Characters

It Chapter Two opens with a few recollections from the first movie, including a shot of Bev in the trappings of the Dead Lights, but the most notable first scene is the savage beating on some gay men in Derry. These men are having a fun time at the local carnival and are then picked on by the local hate group. The group beat one of the gay men to the point that everyone in the audience was audibly uncomfortable. Then they tossed him into the river, where, you guessed it, Pennywise was waiting for him. 

Pennywise the clown with crazy pointy teeth
Time to see the dentist!

This scene
was somewhat out of place but extremely notable. I get it, it’s meant to set up
that fear is back in town. It shows that this movie is about brutality. It just
didn’t involve any of the main characters at all, and it felt strange.

The movie
then brings us up to speed with every character in the Loser’s Club – that’s
right, all seven of them. This is a theme in the movie, “let’s check in with
Bill for five to ten minutes.” which would be fine if there weren’t six to
seven people to catch up with the whole way through the movie. 

Thankfully,
Stan takes pity upon the audience early in the movie and kills himself in the
bathtub when Mike calls him to tell him about the return of Pennywise. 

Midsommar! One of the Best Movies this Year!

https://www.horrormovietalk.com/2019/07/10/midsommar-review/

The Loser’s
Club has become an adult version of themselves. Bev is in an abusive
relationship; Eddie basically married his mom and does risk assessment; Rich is
a comedian. 

The old
Bowers boy was arrested as a youth after killing his father and has been placed
in a prison for the mentally ill. His inclusion in this movie is another point
that could have easily been left out, and the movie wouldn’t have suffered.

The Chinese Restaurant Scene

The Loser’s Club meets for the
first time in years at the Chinese Restaurant in Derry where they quickly fall
into their childhood roles of your mom jokes and noogies. Then the fortune
cookies come out, and things get crazy. Fortune cookies start running amok, and
Mike is left smashing the place up, it’s funny.

It Chapter Two Pennywise smiling a sinister smile
“Heya Bill!”

Finding the Artifacts

Each of the Loser’s need to find their artifact or the thing that ties them to It. Mike basically leads them down the path toward defeating It, and it begins with his knowledge of how It got here. He talked to a Native American tribe, the Shakopee, that had passed down how to beat Pennywise down through their tribe ever since he showed up like a ball of light from outer space in the previous century. They beat it with the ritual of Chud making the light, dark. 

It Chapter Two Scary Grandma
Hey Gram, tell me about Derry.

So, the friends split up to find their respective totems and artifacts. Beverly heads to her old apartment where she meets with the new resident, a kindly grandma who has some strange hostess habits.

Rich heads to the town square park and has a run in with a Paul Bunyun statue that knocked my socks off. I mean, it scared the shit out of me.

Bill finds his old bike for sale in an antiques shop run by Stephen King himself and then runs into Pennywise a few times in the sewer, and a carnival.

Eddie visits the town pharmacist to find the most unsanitary conditions I can imagine in the backroom. There is a vomit comet – it’s super effective.

Eventually the characters find their artifacts and totems, and they are:

  • Bill – Paper boat
  • Eddie – Inhaler
  • Bev – Note from Ben (She thinks it’s from Bill)
  • Ben – Yearbook page Bev signed
  • Rich – Token from arcade
  • Stan – Head wraps from hideout
  • Mike – ? – Mike’s artifact might have been a newspaper clipping detailing his parent’s death

The Action-Laden Ending

I won’t go into terrible detail about the end of this movie, so if that’s something you are dying to hear about, listen to the podcast. What I will say is this movie takes a hard turn when our group goes to confront Pennywise in his lair below the sewer system that they defeated him in in the first chapter. It turns into a spooky action movie.

It Chapter Two Dead Lights little girl

Look, I get it – it’s what happened in the book. Fine. They even set up the weak ending for the whole damn movie by constantly saying that Bill writes weak endings for his books. Bill is the Stephen King stand-in that he includes in every book. It wasn’t super effective for me and it lasted at least ten minutes longer than I felt it needed to.

That being said, it worked to an extent and stayed true to the source material. It’s not like you can just rewrite the ending to perhaps the most iconic horror novel ever written and not get any flack. Plus, what would you do if you went off the source material? It’s already so deep into a weird place that IT may as well be a giant spider!

The group defeats it by shouting it down, minimizing their fears, and taking the bite out of the things they are most scared of.

Final Recommendations for It Chapter Two

If you are a horror fan, this is one of the biggest titles there is, period. It’s not only big, it’s good. The scares are real, the story is compelling, and there are plenty of laughs. Catch this in theaters, and if the thought of a (near) three hour long movie make you tired, bring a pillow because you will still have fun.


There's a particular kind of conversation that happens after the credits roll on a scary movie, when you're dissecting the jump scares and debating the monster's motives. Horror Movie Talk captures that exact feeling, serving up weekly discussions that are as much about the genuine love of the genre as they are about critique. Hosted by a team whose passion is palpable, this podcast delves into everything from the latest chilling release haunting theaters to those hidden gems-or notorious flops-you can find on streaming services. The analysis is sharp and deeply opinionated, but the chemistry between the hosts often leads the conversation into unexpectedly funny territory. It’s this blend of thoughtful review and spontaneous humor that defines the show. You'll hear passionate debates about cinematic technique, nods to classic influences, and honest reactions to whether a film truly delivers the scares. Tuning in each Wednesday feels like pulling up a chair with friends who’ve just seen the same movie, armed with strong opinions and a willingness to laugh at the absurdities that make horror so enduring. For anyone who lives for that post-viewing breakdown, this is a consistently engaging listen.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 464

Horror Movie Talk
Podcast Episodes
Patreon Sneak Peak: American Pyscho Afterpod [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:31
We decided it would be a good idea for all you regular listeners to get a taste of the exclusive Patreon content, and let you know that there is a whole lot more where that came from! This Afterpod was recorded with our…
ThanksKilling Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:16
Happy Thanksgiving everyone! Since it’s so close to the holiday, we decided to review ThanksKilling this week. It’s dumb and bad, but in the best way. In this episode, we give out review, play a round of Taglines, and sh…
Dawn of the Dead (1978) Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:22:25
We saw Dawn of the Dead for free on Youtube because it’s available for free on youtube. This is a Patreon request, so if you want to have a say in what we review, join our Patreon and you will get to weigh in on what we…
The Shining Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:44:19
This week, we are reviewing the prequel to Doctor Sleep, Stanley Kubrick’s masterpiece, and Stephen King’s least favorite adaptation of his work: The Shining. Plue we have a big announcement in “It Came From Social Media…
Doctor Sleep Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:21:30
We saw an early screening of Doctor Sleep, and I was treated to what I believe to be the best horror blockbuster of the year. This is the movie that Brightburn told us it would be. A compelling superhero story with a hor…
The Lighthouse Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:45:59
This week we are reviewing Robert Eggers‘ The Lighthouse. It’s a descent into madness that doesn’t hold your hand. The performances of Willem Defoe and Robert Pattinson are worth the price of admission, but everything re…
Zombieland: Double Tap Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:18:34
We went and saw Zombieland: Double Tap, and I was treated to a fabulous time! This franchise understands it’s audience and really ends up feeling like an excuse for famous actors to get together and have a blast making a…
The Witch Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:54:18
There is a reason why The Witch is considered to be the first movie in the “elevated horror” sub-genre. It raised the stakes for what a great horror movie could be. Think that’s hyperbole? Well listen to our review of Th…
Pumpkinhead Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:16:40
Pumpkinhead is one of the most straightforward and simple movies I think I have ever seen. You know that motif of, “made for TV movie” that movies like Tremors have? Pumpkinhead has that same feeling. While it does hold…
Halloween II (1981) Review [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:38:31
Halloween 2018 would have you believe that Halloween 2 never happened. But it did happen! We watched it. And we’re going to talk about it god damn it! Halloween II Poster Halloween 2 can be found on HBO Now/Go right now,…