Why Today's AI Boom Is No Dot-Com Bubble
Few people experienced the Dot-Com bubble with more vertiginous intensity than Bill Gross, the Pasadena-based founder of Idealab and many many other internet startups over the last 30 years. So when I sat down with Gross at DLD, I couldn’t resist opening with the boom/bubble gambit. How, I asked him, does today’s AI hysteria compare with the Web 1.0 madness of the Nineties? While Gross - whose current ProRata.ai play is focused on protecting creativity in the age of generative AI - doesn’t believe that today’s boom is akin to the Dot-Com bubble, there are similarities. We are at what Gross calls a “Napster moment” in terms of making the big LLMs accountable for all the content they are illegally crawling (ie: stealing). And to get beyond this moment, he says, everyone from Google and OpenAI to Perplexity and Anthropic, needs to move to a “Spotify model” that fairly shares revenue with the human creators of knowledge.
Keen On America is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keenon.substack.com/subscribe
Modern Britain and all that caper: Jonathan Coe on British chocolate, the Royal Family and its decision to marry the wrong Super Power
An Old Story Told Differently: Bethanne Patrick on 8 books reimagining the experience of first generation immigrants
Against the Romance of Transformation: Leon Weiseltier on America's love affair with the promise of personal and social change
Normalizing China: Gilles Guiheux on China's very ordinary history between 1949 and today
Against Green Capitalism: Charles Derber on how big money fuels extinction and what we can do about it
No, Men aren't Angels: Peter Slen on why the Federalist Papers is one of the ten books that has most shaped America
Dumb devices, dumb bureaucrats and dumb entrepreneurs: Keith Teare on FTC chair Lina Khan, FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried and why the iPhone is on the brink of becoming radically more intelligent
Why Disorder may be the New Order: Jason Pack on how the global system itself has gone rogue and no longer conforms with the textbooks
Why Artificial Intelligence will make us smarter: W. Russell Neuman presents AI as a progressive moment in human evolution
An Afterword to Words Themselves? Bethanne Patrick on six speculative novels which imagine a world saturated by AI
Should we punish innovation? Keith Teare on public and private investment markets, breaking up Google and paying to use X
The 10 books that have most shaped America: Peter Slen on Thomas Paine's COMMON SENSE
The White Man's version of Democracy in America? Brook Manville on the "Civic Bargain" that defines the history of democracy in western civilization