1086 - BONUS: Welcome to Plathville REWATCH (s2e2) "My Mystery Man" with Keisha

1086 - BONUS: Welcome to Plathville REWATCH (s2e2) "My Mystery Man" with Keisha

Author: Pink Shade January 8, 2026 Duration: 47:25
*Enjoy this Pink Shade Prime sneak peak! Want more? Join Prime ($10+)*


Mary Payne and Keisha chat about Welcome to Plathville (s2e2) "My Mystery Man". Micah has a HOT photo shoot with Helena. Moriah meets up with her new man, Max (who is not as hot as MP remembers). Barry scars Isaac for life by trying to talk about sex. Ethan annoys Olivia while she's trying to work and he laments his lack of communication skills. And, Lydia tells Moriah about a guy she likes who she hasn't seen in 2 years and she's considering writing him A LETTER (if her parents approve) to express her feelings. Next week - Olivia pierces her belly button!

Watch this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/jUaXCxdIADI

Want more Pink Shade?

Ever find yourself yelling at the TV during a particularly outrageous episode of a reality show? You’re not alone. Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP is that conversation, hosted by Mary Payne Gilbert, who dives deep into the shows that dominate our watercooler talk. This isn't just a summary of what happened; it's a sharp, funny, and often cathartic breakdown of the drama, the decisions, and the sheer audacity we witness on screen. Mary Payne brings her unique perspective to each recap, joined by a rotating cast of co-hosts who add their own flavor to the discussion. New episodes drop three times a week, keeping pace with the relentless flow of content from franchises like WeTV's Love After Lockup universe and TLC's sprawling 90 Day Fiancé saga. Tuning into this podcast feels like grabbing a drink with friends who are just as invested in the absurdity and occasional heart of modern reality television. You'll get analysis, plenty of laughs, and the satisfying sense that someone is articulating exactly what you were thinking from your couch. For anyone who loves to dissect the intricate, messy lives played out on these shows, Pink Shade offers the perfect weekly companion.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP
Podcast Episodes
2017 - Ladies of London (s4 eps 2-3) with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:24:19
MP and Keisha catch up on Ladies of London and we are OBSESSED with this show. On s4e2 "I Know What You Said This Summer", we learn more about Martha and her "Grottage" and we find out Margo is sick of Martha's shenaniga…
2016 - Pop and Bravo with Kate Casey [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 55:56
Mary Payne and buddy Kate Casey chat about this week in the Bravo world. We chat about the new shows coming our way (RHOA, RHORI, The Valley) as well as the shows we are watching (Southern Charm, RHOBH) and we touch on T…
2014 - Ladies of London (s4e1) "The New Reign" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:32
Mary Payne and Keisha are covering a new show and we are so excited! On episode one of Ladies of London (s4e1) "The New Reign" we meet Mark, an antiques collector who is a social animal and loves gossip and scandal. Ther…
2012 - Love is Blind (s10e12) "The Weddings" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 59:09
Mary Payne and Keisha break down the season finale of Love is Blind Ohio! Ashley is our new hero! We aren't sure if Emma and Mike are still together, but we kind of hope they are. Why is Brittany so delusional? Jordan an…
2010 - Love During Lockup (s7e7) "A Messy Conundrum" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 57:18
On this week's episode of LDLU (s7e7) "A Messy Conundrum", MP and Keisha have decided they love Bonita. We aren't sure what Monique did but we know she purposely messed up so she wouldn't have to see Titus. Ayesha's daug…
2009 - Pop & Bravo with Brian Moylan [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:11
Mary Payne chats with Dame Brian J Moylan of The Real Housewives Institute about what we're watching on Bravo and elsewhere this week! We chat about The Traitors, Summer House, RHOBH, and Southern Charm. We gossip about…