1086 - BONUS: Welcome to Plathville REWATCH (s2e2) "My Mystery Man" with Keisha

1086 - BONUS: Welcome to Plathville REWATCH (s2e2) "My Mystery Man" with Keisha

Author: Pink Shade January 8, 2026 Duration: 47:25
*Enjoy this Pink Shade Prime sneak peak! Want more? Join Prime ($10+)*


Mary Payne and Keisha chat about Welcome to Plathville (s2e2) "My Mystery Man". Micah has a HOT photo shoot with Helena. Moriah meets up with her new man, Max (who is not as hot as MP remembers). Barry scars Isaac for life by trying to talk about sex. Ethan annoys Olivia while she's trying to work and he laments his lack of communication skills. And, Lydia tells Moriah about a guy she likes who she hasn't seen in 2 years and she's considering writing him A LETTER (if her parents approve) to express her feelings. Next week - Olivia pierces her belly button!

Watch this episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/jUaXCxdIADI

Want more Pink Shade?

Ever find yourself yelling at the TV during a particularly outrageous episode of a reality show? You’re not alone. Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP is that conversation, hosted by Mary Payne Gilbert, who dives deep into the shows that dominate our watercooler talk. This isn't just a summary of what happened; it's a sharp, funny, and often cathartic breakdown of the drama, the decisions, and the sheer audacity we witness on screen. Mary Payne brings her unique perspective to each recap, joined by a rotating cast of co-hosts who add their own flavor to the discussion. New episodes drop three times a week, keeping pace with the relentless flow of content from franchises like WeTV's Love After Lockup universe and TLC's sprawling 90 Day Fiancé saga. Tuning into this podcast feels like grabbing a drink with friends who are just as invested in the absurdity and occasional heart of modern reality television. You'll get analysis, plenty of laughs, and the satisfying sense that someone is articulating exactly what you were thinking from your couch. For anyone who loves to dissect the intricate, messy lives played out on these shows, Pink Shade offers the perfect weekly companion.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Pink Shade: Reality TV with MP
Podcast Episodes
1087 - 60 Days In (s4e14) "Six Months Later" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:03
TW: This episode contains discussion of suicide and suicide ideation. Please listen/watch with care.Mary Payne and Keisha give our final thoughts on this season of 60 Days in. On this episode 60 Days In (s4e14) "Six Mont…
1084 - 60 Days In (s4e13) "The Aftermath" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:06:43
Mary Payne and Keisha break down the "reunion" episode of 60 Days In (s4e13) called "The Aftermath". We didn't enjoy the set or Stephanie's look but we did enjoy Soledad O'Brien being VERY blunt with the participants. Jo…
1083 - BONUS: The Cult of The Real Housewife (TLC) with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:10:54
Mary Payne and Keisha break down the TLC documentary "The Cult of the Real Housewife" about RHOSLC housewife, Mary Cosby. The documentary takes us through the origin of Faith Temple church and its founder, Mama, and her…
1080 -  60 Days In (s4e12) "Get Them Out" with Keisha [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 56:36
Mary Payne and Keisha chat about the latest episode of 60 Days In (s4e12). Since Angele blew her cover, everyone is in danger and they have to quickly pull everyone out. The episode is nerve wracking as we wait for all t…
1079 - 2025 TLC Year in Review with Kim Cray! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:53
Mary Payne and Kim from 90 Day Fiance Cray Cray go over the shows we covered on TLC this year. There are 13 shows on this list and each one is more amazing than the next! Please note, there is no accompanying video for t…
1078 - Before the 90 Days (s8e3) "Prepare for Takeoff" with Kimberly [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:42:39
https://youtu.be/x3wVcvt2-08Mary Payne and Kimberly chat about Before the 90 Days (s8e3) "Prepare for Takeoff". On this episode, Aviva takes a styrofoam container of shrimp on a plane for 13 hours - that's love! Also, St…