Is Psilocybin Safe for Me? with Seth Mehr, MD

Is Psilocybin Safe for Me? with Seth Mehr, MD

Author: Lynn Marie Morski, MD, JD July 9, 2025 Duration: 52:41

In this episode, Seth Mehr, MD joins to share his expertise on safety planning prior to a patient undergoing psilocybin therapy. After a 20 year career as an Emergency Medicine physician, Seth founded Cascade Psychedelic Medicine in 2021, treating clients with depression, anxiety and PTSD with psychedelic ketamine therapy. He also serves as the Health & Safety Director and a state licensed psilocybin facilitator at the Innertrek service center in Portland, Oregon.

In this conversation, Dr. Mehr outlines key risk categories for psilocybin therapy: medical conditions, medication interactions, and mental health history. He emphasizes the importance of individualized safety planning over binary yes/no decisions. Dr. Mehr discusses specific considerations such as cardiovascular issues, diabetes, serotonergic medications, substance use disorders, suicidal ideation, and family history of psychosis. The conversation also covers strategies for mitigating risk, including delaying treatment, contingency plans, improving support systems, and ensuring informed consent. Throughout, Dr. Mehr stresses a collaborative, nuanced approach that balances potential benefits with careful preparation and personalized care.

 

In this episode, you'll hear:

  • Stories from Dr. Mehr's practice of helping patients with different conditions and histories ensure safe psilocybin experiences
  • Interactions between GLP-1 agonists and psilocybin
  • How Dr. Mehr works with patients who have family histories of psychosis
  • Harm reduction practices which leverage other psychedelics or non-psychedelic interventions to help prepare a client for a psilocybin session
  • Why insulin dependent diabetes can be a contraindication for psychedelic therapy
  • What medication combinations can increase the risk of serotonin toxicity with psilocybin 
  • Supporting clients experiencing spiritual emergency following psilocybin therapy
  • Safety considerations when working with clients who have a history of seizures
  • The importance of having contingency plans if medical emergencies arise during psilocybin therapy
  • The intricacies of providing fully informed consent for psychedelic therapy

 

Quotes:

"There is some evidence now that taking a single serotonergic agent—say, taking Lexapro—and no other medications that increase the risk of serotonin toxicity seems safe where I am not at this point recommending that people stop, skip, or taper a single SSRI in preparation for a psilocybin session due to safety." [12:20]

"One of the difficulties with making these decisions or speaking with some confidence or authority on the matter is that the clinical trials that have been done largely exclude people with lots of conditions—family history and specifically first degree relatives with history of psychosis and bipolar disorder… So we have anecdotal evidence, we have population based surveys to go by. And so when I talk to clients about this, I speak from a place of humility." [27:30]

"I always emphasize to clients that while we're talking about a specific safety issue like serotonin toxicity, we don't want to trade that for psychological instability and crisis and declare success because we've helped somebody taper off of a medication that seems less safe and now they aren't sleeping, they're agitated, they're depression is worse, their suicidality is worse. So we have to take a holistic approach to this and consider the totality of what's happening with that client."  [36:45]

"There are so many different components to trying to set somebody up for success rather than a yes/no, black and white approach [to psilocybin therapy]." [48:44]

 

Links:

Cascade Psychedelic Medicine website

InnerTrek website

Managing Medical Risk In Patients Seeking Psilocybin Therapy CME/CE Course

Psychedelic Medicine Association

Porangui

 


Exploring the frontier of mind and medicine, the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast with Dr. Lynn Marie Morski delves into the complex world of psychedelic substances and their potential to heal. Hosted by Lynn Marie Morski, a physician and attorney, this podcast navigates the intricate intersection of cutting-edge science, clinical practice, and evolving policy. Each episode brings a grounded, expert perspective to conversations about psilocybin, MDMA, ketamine, LSD, ayahuasca, ibogaine, and other compounds, moving beyond hype to examine the real-world implications of this therapeutic renaissance. Listeners will hear detailed discussions on the latest peer-reviewed research, practical insights from medical professionals integrating these approaches, and thoughtful analysis of the legal landscape shaping access. The dialogue is rooted in a commitment to safety, ethics, and evidence, offering a clear-eyed look at both the profound promise and the challenges inherent in psychedelic medicine. Whether you're a healthcare provider, a patient, a researcher, or simply intellectually curious, this podcast provides an essential, nuanced resource for understanding how these ancient and modern substances are reshaping perspectives on mental health, consciousness, and treatment. It’s a space for serious inquiry, where complex questions about healing, neuroscience, and society are met with informed, accessible conversation.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

Psychedelic Medicine Podcast with Dr. Lynn Marie Morski
Podcast Episodes
Who Is a Good Candidate for Ibogaine? with Fernando Rivas, MD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:32
In this episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Fernando Rivas, MD, joins to unpack the safety and screening considerations for ibogaine therapy. Dr. Rivas is an emergency physician with over 15 years of clinical ex…
Encore Episode: Psychedelics and Breathwork with Kyle Buller [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:58
This encore episode of the Psychdelic Medicine Podcast features a conversation with Kyle Buller on psychedelics and breathwork. Kyle is co-founder and host of the Psychedelics Today podcast and he has studied breathwork…
Psychedelics and Psychosis with Alexander Lebedev, MD, PhD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:09
In this episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Alexander Lebedev, MD, PhD joins to discuss psychedelic medicine and psychosis. Dr. Lebedev is a physician-scientist, medical AI engineer, and entrepreneur working at…
Psychedelics and GLP-1s with Arsalan Azam, MD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 36:22
In this episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Arsalan Azam, MD joins to unpack the intersection between psychedelics and GLP-1s. Dr. Azam, founder of Daydream MD, completed his residency in Emergency Medicine at t…
Psilocybin vs. Ketamine with Dori Lewis, LPC [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:11
In this episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Dori Lewis, MA, MEd, LPC-S returns to discuss the differences between psilocybin and ketamine. Dori is the Clinical Director of Elemental Psychedelics and Owner/Operat…
Choosing the Right Ketamine Clinic for You with Katie Fassbinder, MD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 50:19
In this episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Katie Fassbinder, MD joins to explore how to choose the right ketamine clinic. Dr. Fassbinder is the Faculty Medical Lead for ketamine-assisted psychotherapy training…
The Future of Psychedelic Medicine with Ismail Lourido Ali, JD [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 52:24
In the 200th episode of the Psychedelic Medicine Podcast, Ismail Lourido Ali, JD joins to discuss the future of psychedelic medicine. Ismail serves as MAPS Co-Executive Director and has been actively participating in the…
Psychedelics and Neurodiversity with Dr. WaiFung Tsang, DClinPsy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 43:31
In this episode, Dr. WaiFung Tsang, DClinPsy joins to discuss the intersection of psychedelics and neurodiversity. Dr. Tsang is a clinical research psychologist from Hong Kong, musician, and student of Shipibo curanderis…