Did I Just Get Promoted or Fired?

Did I Just Get Promoted or Fired?

Author: Startups.com September 22, 2025 Duration: 42:29

Ever wonder what happens when a founder gets 'promoted' out of the CEO role? Ryan and Will dive into the tricky terrain of founder transitions, exploring how it feels to be nudged into roles like Chief Vision Officer or Chairman—positions that often come when a new CEO is brought in. They discuss the emotions involved, the motivations of investors, and the strategies for turning this awkward moment into an opportunity. Whether you're in the thick of this situation or just want to be prepared, this episode provides valuable insights on maintaining dignity, negotiating effectively, and leveraging a graceful exit for future success.

Resources:
Startup Therapy Podcast
https://www.startups.com/community/startup-therapy
Website
https://www.startups.com/begin
LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/company/startups-co/

Join our Network of Top Founders
Wil Schroter
https://www.linkedin.com/in/wilschroter/
Ryan Rutan
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryan-rutan/

What to listen for:
00:24 The Founder Promotion Dilemma
01:07 Personal Experience with Founder Titles
02:26 The Gary Coleman Effect
03:21 The CEO Replacement Backfire
05:29 The Emotional and Financial Impact of Founder Reassignment
10:44 Board Mechanics and Founder Control
13:06 Investor Strategies and Founder Leverage
18:34 Facing the Reality of Founder Reassignment
23:17 Famous Comebacks: Steve Jobs, Howard Schultz, and Jack Dorsey
24:36 The Emotional Toll of Being Replaced
25:10 Turning Emotions into Positive Actions
25:46 Negotiating Your Exit Strategy
30:54 Crafting Your New Role
31:55 The Importance of Maintaining Relationships
37:00 The Worst and Best Case Scenarios


Building a company is far more chaotic and personal than any business school case study lets on. Startup Therapy from Startups.com digs into that reality, moving past polished success stories to focus on the raw, unvarnished journey. Hosts Wil Schroter and Ryan Rutan, who have each navigated these trenches themselves, lead conversations that feel more like essential conversations between founders than a standard interview show. They tackle the specific pressures that come with trying to transform an idea into something meaningful-the financial strain, the team dynamics, the personal sacrifices, and the frequent moments of doubt that rarely make the keynote speech. This podcast operates on a simple premise: the best guidance comes from those who have been there, not from abstract theory. Each episode is a candid session, dissecting the professional hurdles and the intense emotional toll that founders manage daily. You’ll hear direct talk about fundraising fails, partnership conflicts, burnout, and the small victories that keep everything moving forward. It’s a resource for anyone in the thick of building something, offering practical perspectives and a sense of shared experience when the path gets especially tough. The dialogue is straightforward and focused on actionable insight, providing a genuine look at the resilience required to change the world, one startup at a time.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Startup Therapy
Podcast Episodes
Will the Payout be Worth the Sacrifice? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 44:13
The challenging question of whether the sacrifices made in pursuit of entrepreneurial success are ultimately worth the payoff. Will retells his personal story of almost buying an expensive house in Bel Air only to realiz…
How Founders Blow Their Fortunes [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:21
The critical do's and don’ts after a big financial win as a startup founder. They emphasize the importance of not oversharing about your wealth, shifting from an offensive to a defensive mindset, preserving your gains, a…
When is Enough, Enough? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:37
Ryan and will talks about a critical issue many founders face: knowing when to say 'enough is enough.' They explore the constant pursuit of growth both personally and professionally and how it can turn into a liability i…
Can Entrepreneurship Alleviate Poverty? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 47:57
How entrepreneurship can transform lives and communities? Will shares his personal journey from a challenging childhood to becoming a successful entrepreneur. They explore whether entrepreneurship can be a means to allev…
Should Startups Be a Family? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 37:22
In this episode of the Startup Therapy Podcast, Ryan and Will discuss the challenges and dynamics of blending friendship and professionalism in startups. They delve into the potential pitfalls of treating your startup te…
Can Founders be Replaced by AI? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:05
Ryan and Will talk about the growing role of AI in startups. They explore how AI is automating traditional founder tasks like writing, coding, and analyzing data. The conversation delves into the existential threat AI po…
What if we run out of goals? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:59
In this episode of the Startup Therapy Podcast, Ryan and Will talk about what happens when you hit all your big goals and realize there might not be any more mountains left to climb. They discuss the complex feelings and…
Founders, Reinvention IS your Constant! [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:06
Will and Ryan talk about the fascinating and often overlooked journey of reinventing oneself. Will shares his diverse background, from being an ad guy to becoming a multi-time startup founder, and stresses the importance…
Founder Isolation is Getting Worse [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:22
Ryan and Will talk about the growing isolation that founders are feeling despite having more ways to connect. They delve into how the shift to remote work, the impact of social media, and the rise of AI have contributed…
Forging Founder Confidence [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 39:22
Ryan and Will discuss the journey of becoming a confident founder. Celebrating their 300th episode, they reflect on how learning to lead and building confidence starts with curiosity. They emphasize asking questions, eve…