EP | 744 - How to Fix Your Show Rates | 5 Systems That Get Your Booked Calls to Actually Show Up

EP | 744 - How to Fix Your Show Rates | 5 Systems That Get Your Booked Calls to Actually Show Up

Author: Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger May 18, 2026 Duration: 20:22

Let me give you a number. 1.8 million.

That's roughly what a single metric cost us in annualized front-end revenue in early 2025. Not a bad hire. Not a broken offer. Not an ad account getting shut down.

One number. That we let slip.

Here's the math so you understand the stakes before we even get into the fix.

At IFCA we run about 300 booked calls a month. We approve roughly 75% of those — 225 calls. The other 75 get dequeued. Either they don't qualify or our team proactively pulls them off the calendar so they don't pollute our data. So we're working with 225 approved calls.

At a 25% close rate and a $9,500 average contract value — here's what happens at different show rates.

At 73%, which was our historical baseline, 164 of those 225 people show up live. You close 25%. That's 41 new clients. Roughly $390,000 in front-end cash for the month.

In early 2025, our show rate dropped to 45%. 101 people showing up live. 25 closes. $238,000 in front-end cash.

Same calendar. Same closer. Same ad spend. $152,000 a month difference. $1.8 million annualized.

And before I tell you how we got there, I want to make something clear: this was not a lead quality problem. I hear coaches say that all the time when their show rate tanks. "The leads are just worse now." Sometimes that's partially true. But a 45% show rate is almost never a lead quality problem. It is a system failure. It has an operational cause and an operational solution.

I'll share what that operational solution is in today's episode.

 

Time Stamps:

 

(0:10) Fixing Show Rates

(2:04) Show Rate Optmiziation Guide

(2:34) Why Show Rates Are Dropping

(6:20) Finding The Gaps In Your Sales Workflow

(11:07) Justification Mode

(16:48) Maximum Calendar Availability

----------------

🚀 Watch Our 3 Minute Video on How to Unlock An Extra $30k/Month In Your Online Fitness Coaching Business In Just 90 Days - Or We'll Coach You For Free!

----------------

Follow Us on Instagram


Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger have built a seven-figure online coaching company, Transform 4Ever Systems, by focusing on more than just workouts. Their The Fitness Business Podcast with Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger digs into that exact intersection where physical transformation meets entrepreneurial growth. Each episode feels like a candid conversation between two practitioners who are actively solving the complex problems fitness professionals face daily. You’ll hear them unpack the nuances of client communication, the psychology behind effective marketing, and the leadership strategies required to scale a coaching practice sustainably. This isn't a theoretical discussion; it's grounded in their real-world experience of building a successful brand from the ground up. While the core audience is fitness entrepreneurs and coaches, anyone with a serious interest in the business mechanics behind health and nutrition will find immense value. The dialogue moves seamlessly from the science of achieving physical results to the practical art of selling and influencing in a crowded market. Tuning into this podcast offers a direct line to the mindset and tactics used by operators who are in the trenches, making it a unique resource for those who want their passion for fitness to translate into a viable, impactful career. It’s for those who understand that changing a body and running a business are two sides of the same coin.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

The Fitness Business Podcast with Erin Dimond and Jordan Dugger
Podcast Episodes
EP | 746 - We Sold IFCA. Here's the Whole Story (ft. Taeler De Haes) [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 32:09
We've made the biggest decision in our professional career and the result is the two best coaching education programs in this industry just merged into one. We have officially sold Impact Fitness Coaching Academy to Tael…
EP | 742 - How To Close A Sales Call In Under 40 Mins [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 10:34
One of the biggest mistakes I see online coaches make on sales calls is they think the more they explain… the more likely someone is to buy. And it's actually the opposite. The more complicated you make something, the mo…