The Comps Illusion: Why Aircraft Sales Data Isn’t What You Think It Is | EPISODE 29

The Comps Illusion: Why Aircraft Sales Data Isn’t What You Think It Is | EPISODE 29

Author: Jason Zilberbrand March 24, 2026 Duration: 21:59

Podcast: The Truth About the Market Host: Jason Zilberbrand, President of VREF

Most people in aviation believe they understand the market.

  • They look at comps
  • They reference recent sales
  • They trust the numbers

But what if those numbers aren’t as real as they seem?

In this episode of The Truth About the Market, Jason pulls back the curtain on one of the most widely accepted—and least questioned—foundations of aircraft valuation: comparable sales data.

  • Because in aviation, there is no centralized system
  • No verified database
  • No public record of what aircraft actually sell for.

And yet… entire markets move based on what those comps supposedly say.

This isn’t about bad actors, it’s about a system that was never designed for transparency—and the quiet risks that come with relying on it.

In This Episode, You’ll Discover

  • Why there is no “MLS” for aircraft—and why there never will be
  • How over 95% of aircraft transactions are never publicly disclosed
  • Where comp data actually comes from (and why it’s often secondhand)
  • The hidden pipeline of phone calls, conversations, and voluntary reporting
  • Why most reported sales numbers are never verified against real contracts
  • What aircraft purchase agreements reveal—and why no one sees them
  • How deal structures (credits, concessions, trades) distort headline prices
  • Why a reported price is often only a fraction of the real transaction
  • The concentration problem: how a small number of voices shape the entire market
  • Why the same data gets repeated until it feels like confirmation
  • The “echo chamber effect” that creates false confidence in pricing
  • How financial incentives can quietly influence reported values
  • Why strong comps can support inventory—and weak comps can shift leverage
  • The difference between reported numbers and real economic outcomes
  • How lenders, buyers, and investors unknowingly absorb this risk
  • Why sales comps are often treated as facts—but function as narratives
  • The critical mistake of confusing isolated transactions with market structure
  • What actually determines aircraft values: inventory, demand, maintenance cycles, and capital
  • Why transaction velocity matters more than a handful of reported deals
  • And the principle every serious operator needs to understand: what gets reported is not always what happened—and what happened doesn’t always get reported

The Bottom Line

Comps are not the market. They are fragments, snapshots and often incomplete reflections of much more complex transactions.

And when those fragments are treated as truth, the risk doesn’t disappear, it transfers. Because in aviation, pricing isn’t determined by a few reported numbers, it’s determined by the system behind them—supply, demand, liquidity, and timing. And if you’re not looking at that system, you’re not seeing the market clearly.

For accurate, defensible aircraft valuations trusted by lenders, insurers, and aviation professionals worldwide, visit VREF.com.

Fly safe. Stay smart.


Hosted by Jason Zilberbrand, VREF | The Truth About the Aviation Market cuts through the noise to deliver clear-eyed analysis on how aircraft hold and lose their value. This isn't just industry news; it's a deep dive into the economic forces, market trends, and regulatory shifts that directly impact valuation. Each episode leverages the authoritative perspective of VREF, a leader in appraisal services, translating complex market data into actionable insights. Whether you're a pilot, an owner, an investor, or simply fascinated by the business of flight, you'll find a grounded conversation that connects the dots between current events and your bottom line. The discussions are built for those who operate where leisure, business, and aviation intersect, offering a unique lens on asset management and market intelligence. Tune in for a candid and expert-driven exploration of what really drives the aviation marketplace, making this podcast an essential tool for anyone with a stake in the skies.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

VREF | The Truth About the Aviation Market
Podcast Episodes
The Most Expensive "Peace of Mind" In Aviation | EP 56 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 42:31
An owner has been paying into an engine program for 11 years.More than $1 million contributed.The airplane is worth roughly $3 million.And the overhaul those payments are supposed to protect him from is still four to fiv…
The Market Split In Half: The Numbers Don't Lie | EP 55 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 46:13
The September 1 VREF value revision is live—and the numbers tell a very different story than the broad “strong market” or “weak market” headlines.Business jet transaction volume is down nearly 19% year to date, essential…
The "Ferrari Problem" Is Coming For Aviation | EP 53 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:08
How does an entire market start pricing assets at numbers buyers have never actually paid?That’s the question behind Episode 53 of The Truth About the Market.And although Jason starts with Ferrari, this episode is really…
The $2 Million Loss Your Insurance May Never Mention | EP 52 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:45
An $8 million Citation CJ4 is sitting on a ramp. The owner isn’t flying it. He isn’t even in the country. A line guy hooks up a tug, gets distracted, and tows it into a hangar improperly.Forty seconds later, the damage i…
The "Red Hot" Jet That No One Is Selling | EP 51 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 30:16
In this episode, we cover:• Why the Challenger 3500 has become the industry’s favorite proof that the super-midsize market is running hot• What Jason found after reviewing every recorded Challenger 3500 transfer• How man…
Aviation's Alphabet Mafia | EP 50 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:10
In this episode, we cover:• What public IRS Form 990 filings reveal about executive compensation• The reported compensation of the National Business Aviation Association’s president and CEO• How additional compensation c…
The Jet That’s Worth More Dead Than Alive | EP 49 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:00
In this mailbag episode of The Truth About the Market, Jason answers a question from Paul Bordeaux, Chief Pilot at Hargrove Engineers and Constructors:How should a buyer evaluate future demand for an out-of-production bu…
Oshkosh: Where Dreams, Deals, and Bad Numbers Collide | EP 48 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:43
In this episode, we cover:• Why Oshkosh is the largest aircraft transaction event nobody calls a transaction event• How more than 700,000 people and 10,000 aircraft turn AirVenture into a live market signal• Why deals at…
Why Some Airplanes Sell In Days While Others Just Sit | EP 47 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 25:43
In this episode, we cover:• Why “the aircraft market” is never just one market• Why the better question is not whether the market is up or down, but which market you are talking about• Why some aircraft still sell in day…