022 - Battle Royale vol. 15

022 - Battle Royale vol. 15

Author: We Appreciate Manga™ August 31, 2019 Duration: 52:58

EXPLICIT CONTENT! The final volume to Battle Royale! We finished recording this run in October 2018. Listen as we recount the tropes used, the differences between the source material and the goal of the authors. Skip the synopsis @ minute 12:00

022: Battle Royale vol. 15

Art: Masayuki Taguchi

Story: Koushun Takami

Translation by Keith Giffen

Topics:

·       Kiriyama's death

·       Kawada's betrayal

·       The authors

…and their intentions with the book and handling violence

 

Differences between the Japanese and English translation:

 

(Note: the English Vol 1 was released in 2003,

same year the Japanese vol 9 came out, both the English and Japanese runs ended in 2006)

 

'"It's a good story that Takami is telling", Giffen said. "What I do is go in and make bad scenes that much worse. I loved the movie of Battle Royale, and also love the manga. I just wanted to do it right. I wanted to do justice to it, and I knew I couldn't get away with doing a straight translation, because it would be horrifyingly bad."' – Keith Giffen

 

§  There isn't a reality TV show aspect

§  Sakura doesn't make any bets prior to the program

§  Izumi was at the reef before Kiriyama and the rest arrived. This means Kiriyama would have flipped the coin on meeting Kazumi and way before the others arrived. It also means there was no allusion to rape what-so-ever.

§  Originally Niida makes up excuses for his actions and isn't as psychotic as he is in the English version.

 

Basically, Keith Geifen makes it a lot darker than the comic needs to be.

 

 

Differences between other adaptations:

 

·       Yonemi Kamon is an original character that replaces, Kinpatsu Sakamochi in the novel and Kitano in the movie.

·       In the movie, Kazuo Kiriyama is one of two transfer students, the other is Shogo Kawada. They are specially selected to take part in the Battle Royale program and have no prior relationship to the other students.

·       In the novel Soma is setting the campfires to cause confusion, until Kiriyama tracks her down and kills her. Then Kiriyama continues setting the smoke signals.

·       Kiriyama decides to take part in the Battle Royale before his gang arrives, having killed Izumi kanai before they arrive.

 

 

Pop culture references: 

 

·       "A star is born kiddies" Mirroring Soma's line, a reference to the film 'A Star is Born'.

 

·       "News flash, Oz is a slum, the white knight's a retard and the seven dwarfs gang rape pixies" – Shojo Kawada

1.)  Frank L Baum's  The Wizard of Oz (Judy Garland movie, is Keith a fan?)

2.)   White Knight:

Medieval trope that is derived from myths of courtship and valour. It's a very respectable title but common usage can be derogatory as of 2010.

First records of anyone having the white knight title is the Fitzgibbon and Fitzgerald family of Ireland. Fitz-suffix meaning they were either raised by or were illegitimate sons (bastards).

Modern culture shows we've given such titles to sports heroes. 3 lions are worn by the English soccer team, not soldiers! And Russian hockey player Evgeni 'Geno' Malkin is nicknamed 'white knight' according to Wikipedia.

 

3.)   Snow White and the Seven dwarfs (Brothers Grimm story, famously Disney's first feature length movie)

 

·       Kawada calls Nanahara "Pollyanna" once again. 3x now!!! Based on the titular character of Eleanor H. Porter's novel.

 

 

Product placement:

 

·       7-Up (Soda-pop drink owned by Pepsi outside the U.S.)

·       Coca Cola (world famous caffeinated Soda-pop drink, originally marketed as an elixir)

·       SuperTrapp (motorcycles and gear retailer)

 

 

Notable Tropes:

 

·       Tsundere  (Takako Chigusa)

·       Playing Possum (Frogboy with the Kevlar vest)

·       Chi energy powers (Sugimura)

·       Femme Fatale (Mistuko Soma)

·       The determinator/implacable man

             (Kazuo Kiriyama)

·       The stoic (Kiriyama and Kawada)

·       Mind vs Heart paradigm a.k.a. the tin woodsman and scarecrow thesis

(Nanahara and Kawada)

 

For a more comprehensive list visit the TV Tropes website.

 

 

Synopsis:

 

Mere days ago, 42 school students were marooned on an island, given random weapons and ordered to kill each other in a brutal game of death. Now only 4 remain… but that's still 3 too many.

 

Nanahara, Noriko and Kawada team up to defeat Kazuo Kiriyama, the most dangerous competitor of the students. Nanahara makes the killing shot, as he watches Kiriyama die, Nanahara expresses regret and wishes that he could have saved him. Kiriyama's final words being "I can feel again".

 

Kawada takes Noriko and Nanahara to the end of the island by the edge of the cliff. He pulls his gun on both of them and wins the game.

 

He is escorted off the island by boat, he is not given any aid or chance to clean himself before Mr. Kamon enters the cabin to question him. Kamon suspects Kawada for faking the death of Noriko and Nanahara, his evidence to support this suspicion is that documents about the explosive collars and the chosen class were hacked into before the game began. he tells Kawada that helicopters are flooding the island with poison as they speak and pulls a gun on Kawada.

 

Mr. Kamon is distracted due to Nanahara's ambush on the boat. Kawada kills Kamon with a pencil to the neck. He goes onto the upper deck where he finds Nanahara and Noriko have kept the guards subdued and tied down. When one guard breaks loose he attacks Kawada but Nanahara takes the bullet as Kawada shoots the guard's hand off. Nanahara is protected by the Kevlar vest he took from Kiriyama. The 3 send the guards into a dingy and cut them loose.

 

As Kawada teaches Nanahara how to control the ship he succumbs to the sustained gunshot wound from Kiriyama. Kawada dies on the ship.

 

Both Noriko and Nanahara become wanted criminals during the Christmas holidays. They discover Kawada's plan was to die in that game but rescue Shinji Mimura, in doing so they would declare war on the program. Mimura's aunt is kind enough to secure a boat to the U.S. for Nanahara and Noriko but before they leave Nanahara spies on Miss Ryoko to see if she is safe and Noriko calls her mother. The two make their peace with the students they fought and start a new life in the U.S.

 

The End.

 

 

Instagram –  weappreciatemanga.co.uk

Twitter - @RealJamesFitton

Website – Weappreciatemanga.com

Email – Weappreciatemanga@gmail.com

 

 


There's a particular kind of magic that happens when a friend hands you a book they love, especially when that book is a manga. We Appreciate Manga captures that exact feeling, beginning each conversation with a personal recommendation before letting the discussion wander into deeper territory. Hosted by the team at We Appreciate Manga™, this series is less a formal review and more like eavesdropping on a thoughtful, sometimes rambling, chat between enthusiasts. You’ll hear them explore how specific stories resonate, why certain artistic choices matter, and the very real comfort these illustrated narratives can provide during difficult periods. It’s a celebration of the medium that goes beyond plot summaries to appreciate manga as a unique and powerful form of visual storytelling. Think of it as your audio companion to a vibrant, anime-adjacent book club where the panels come to life through conversation. New episodes of this podcast have been available since August 2022, offering a consistent space to connect with the art and heart of these stories.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 136

We Appreciate Manga
Podcast Episodes
136 - Petshop of Horrors: Flowers and Detective [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:54
Is this the final episode of 'We Appreciate Manga'? I guess we will have to see… Either way James has an announcement to make but first we give a quick review of Godzilla minus one and talk about side chapters of Petshop…
135 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 10 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 37:51
Author Matsuri closes out the final chapters and leaves no stone unturned, Chris speaks, Q-Chan shows off their human form and a climatic meeting with D's father finally happens. In a clever way, Matsuri switches from an…
134 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 9 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 40:05
Listen with discretion and care since on today's episode we speak about intergenerational trauma, modern slavery, and human trafficking. Pretty intense stuff for a fantasy manga but Akino Matsuri is an expert anthologist…
133 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 8 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 38:30
Come join our book club and listen as we read Akino Matsuri's horror stories, one that is about a mermaid. Another about a family that move into a house that has a dark history. And a woman who seems to have looks, fame…
132 - Petshop of Horror vol. 7 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 41:42
Today we talk about the importance of character-based story telling superseding social and political commentary, be it human trafficking, weight loss and police brutality. Albeit a fantasy story, there is an argument tha…
131 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 6 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 34:33
Continuing with their book club podcast, Will and James talk about volume 6 of the surreal fantasy horror josei manga, Petshop of Horrors! Today's stories are very much a reflection on the chaos of childhood and the pres…
130 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 5 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 45:36
A poignant volume that introduces a new character to the lore and explores feelings around death and childhood. And it may come as no surprise that even a horror Shoujo manga somehow has to reference ballet, we all seen…
129 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 4 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 48:13
Does anyone remember Tamagotchi? Or maybe you had a Giga-Pet growing up? Whatever the case a virtual pet goes by many brand names and today we read one story that is both inspired by the virtual pet craze of the 90's and…
128 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 3 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 44:17
Dog lovers will love this one yet we are now seeing author Akino experiment with the characters. She also explores some social commentary and posing morally difficult questions. It goes without saying, today is a heavy e…
127 - Petshop of Horrors vol. 2 [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 37:15
Cat lovers will enjoy the continuation of our spooky season read along, as James and Will experience multiple stories from the Petshop of Horror. There's one about a dangerous mermaid that resembles someone's dead wife,…