Episode 158: Taking One for the Team

Episode 158: Taking One for the Team

Author: Mr & Mrs Jones's Swinging Adventures July 22, 2026 Duration: 1:06:40

The phrase "taking one for the team" is often treated as a hard boundary in ethical non-monogamy, but we think the reality is far more nuanced. For us, attraction is rarely determined by physical appearance alone. Decisions about whether to pursue a connection are influenced by a combination of factors including chemistry, personality, intelligence, behavior, relationship dynamics, safety, sobriety, and sometimes that unexplainable "ick" factor. 

We also discuss whether there are times when "taking one for the team" can actually be a positive experience. When you feel emotionally and physically safe, genuinely enjoy someone's company, and trust a couple you've come to know, a lack of immediate physical attraction or chemistry doesn't necessarily have to end the conversation. By keeping an open mind, couples may discover rewarding experiences and relationships they otherwise would have overlooked.

Ultimately, deciding whether to play should always be a mutual decision made without pressure, guilt, or obligation—and any "no" should be accepted graciously and without lingering consequences. We believe there is a spectrum between holding out for the elusive perfect four-way connection and feeling obligated to "take one for the team." 

Mentioned in this episode:

Contact Mr Jones for a promo code to try the We Gotta Thing community for three months!

Strictly Anonymous podcast with Mr Jones cancer story

Book your Desire Resorts trip here

Music used with permission from Luxe Music Studios:
We Gotta Thing
Playtime 
Dressed to Undress

More Than Monogamy documentary


Ever wondered how a shared adventure might change the view from your own front porch? That’s the space explored in We Gotta Thing-A Swinger Podcast, hosted by a couple who’ve been married for years. As Mr. and Mrs. Jones, they’re not here with a rulebook or a checklist. Instead, each episode unfolds from their own ongoing journey, focusing on how the swinging lifestyle has become a surprising tool for connection and self-discovery within their long-term partnership. You’ll hear their candid reflections on the conversations that happen before, during, and after, tackling everything from navigating jealousy and setting boundaries to the unexpected ways this path has influenced their fitness goals and overall well-being. This podcast is less about instructions and more about exploration-a series of "what if" discussions designed to spark genuine dialogue between partners. It’s for those who are curious, those who are just starting, and those already within the lifestyle who recognize the value of shared stories. By weaving together topics of relationships, sexuality, and personal health with broader cultural perceptions, they offer a grounded, personal narrative. Tune in for honest talk that demystifies and humanizes, helping you and your partner consider where, or if, you might find your own place in such a lifestyle.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 50

We Gotta Thing - Exploring Non-Monogamy
Podcast Episodes
Episode 162: Where Non-monogamy Intersects with Real Life [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:08:07
Non-monogamy can be about much more than sex with other people. For us, it has enriched our relationship, created meaningful friendships, and changed the way we move through everyday life. In this episode, we explore how…
Episode 161: How Feelings Make Us Feel [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:28:45
Emotions are having a moment—and they're affecting everything from our broader culture to our most intimate relationships. In this episode, Kel from Expansive Connection joins us to explore how fear of uncomfortable feel…
Episode 159: So You Think You Want to Kink? [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:26:34
Kink is often misunderstood, wrapped in myths, stereotypes, and cultural taboos that obscure what it's really about. In this episode, we unpack what kink is—and just as importantly, what it isn't. From broad definitions…
Episode 157: Erotic Compatibility and Non-Monogamy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:33:45
What if the key to greater pleasure, connection, and fulfillment is understanding your unique erotic wiring? In this episode, we explore the Erotic Blueprints™, a framework developed by somatic sexologist Jaiya that help…
Episode 156: Opening the Circle [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:35:49
In this episode, Dr Mitch from Expansive Connection joins us as we explore the powerful idea of "Opening the Circle" — the human need to feel welcomed, included, and connected. We talk about how the first question most p…
Episode 155: Redefining the Swinging Lifestyle [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:07:42
In this episode we are reframing the traditional concept of "swinging" by moving away from labels that feel intimidating or misleading and instead embracing the broader concept of ethical non-monogamy. While the term "sw…
Episode 154: Why Comparison is the Thief of Joy [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:12:47
In this episode, Kel from Expansive Connection discusses the pervasive issue of comparison, its roots in human evolution, and practical tools to manage it. The conversation explores how comparison impacts self-esteem, re…
Episode 153: Your Insecurity is Your Issue [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:07
We've talked about jealousy, we've talked about body image. We've discussed learning to flirt and being corageous in the lifestyle. But beneath the surface we all have insecurities about ourselves at the root of all thes…
Episode 152: Managing Anxiety in the Lifestyle [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 53:54
There are no shortage of lifestyle sitiuations that will cause us some anxiety! Visiting a club for the first time, going on a first date, being rejected by others, wondering if our partner will 'find someone better,' pe…