Why thinking What's In It For Them will improve your pitch success rate

Why thinking What's In It For Them will improve your pitch success rate

Author: Rachel Spencer May 7, 2024 Duration: 23:30

Are you looking to approach content creators to feature your pet business?

In this podcast episode, I'm talking about why thinking 'What's in it for them,' rather than 'What's in it for me,' will drastically improve your pitch success rate.

One of the exercises I do with my clients is to ask them to create a ‘wishlist’ of publications where they’d like to be published.

Regularly, people will get in touch and say, ‘I want to be in this magazine or on this podcast or work with this blogger.’

It might be a brand they’d love to collaborate with and they want to know the best way to approach it.

And the key to success is to think, ‘What’s in it for them?’ What is in it for the journalist, content creator or brand in featuring or working with you?

In this episode you'll learn how 'What's in it for them' works as a pitching approach, and how you can use it to improve your success rate.

Key topics and timings in this episode:

0.10 - Intro

0.30 - Pets Get Visible sponsors this episode - find out more here: Is my Pets Get Visible membership right for you?

2.01 - What 'what's in it for them' means

3.26 - Building and nurturing relationships

7.07 - Respecting time and value exchange

9.29 - Why you shouldn't be surprised if you're asked for money

10.00 - What is a value exchange?

13.21 - Using the personal touch in pitching

14.49 - Rachel's pitching examples

18.35 - Pitching examples from pet business owners Wendy, Kerry and Louise

23.46 - Conclusion and next steps

Links mentioned in this episode:

If you’d like a pitch framework, you can download my free podcast pitching guide here.

And for further, personalised support on your ideas, come and join Pets Get Visible.

Your first month is only £15 and you can get started here.

Further reading on this topic

Is my Pets Get Visible membership right for you?

How to pitch yourself as a podcast guest

How to be the perfect podcast guest

Working with bloggers and influencers with Vicky Gunn

Best podcasts for the pet industry

Visibility lessons from Sunnyside Cottage


There's a persistent myth in the pet industry that success requires a rigid, one-size-fits-all formula. Your Pet Business, Your Way exists to dismantle that idea entirely. Hosted by Rachel Spencer, a journalist and accredited coach with deep roots in this world, this podcast is a conversation for pet professionals-groomers, trainers, walkers, product makers-who feel exhausted by generic marketing advice and industry trends that clash with their personal values and lifestyle. Rachel brings her background as a mentor and author to frank discussions about building a sustainable enterprise that doesn't demand you sacrifice your family time, your sanity, or your unique voice. Episodes delve into practical strategies for marketing, client relationships, and entrepreneurship, but always through the lens of your individual circumstances. You'll hear from Rachel directly, as well as insights from others navigating the same path, focusing on how to grow a business that genuinely fits around your life, whether that involves kids, other passions, or simply a desire for more autonomy. This isn't about following a rulebook; it's about writing your own. Tune in for a refreshingly realistic take on creating a pet business that thrives on your terms, making this podcast a trusted resource for anyone who believes their love for animals and their personal ambitions can truly coexist.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

Your pet business, Your way
Podcast Episodes
Behind the scenes of the 2026 Pet Business Content Planner launch [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 28:35
Are you planning to launch a new product or service and want to get an idea of what to expect?This episode is a behind the scenes account of launching my Pet Business Content Planner for 2026.This is a product I created…
How to have a spring reset in your pet business [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 24:25
Did you come into the New Year feeling all fired up and filled with energy about your pet business and what was going to happen in 2026?Then, as we were flung into wars, political upheaval, economic uncertainty, did it f…
15 lessons from 15 years of Theo Paphitis' Small Business Sunday [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 35:08
Each year, Theo Paphitis hosts the Small Business Sunday winner’s event to celebrate small businesses and give them a boost.It’s a brilliantly inspiring day where Theo and a line-up of speakers share lessons, practical a…
How to become a more confident writer with Rikki Sullivan [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:13:36
Rikki Sullivan is The Canine Copywriter - a specialist dog copywriter and marketing strategist who helps pet professionals put themselves out there without wrecking their nervous system.In this episode, we talk about con…
How to write a press release for your pet business [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 33:23
Do you need to write a press release about your pet business?You're in the right place!This episode will cover everything you need to know when it comes to creating a press release for your pet business.But what I’m real…