Melanie Mitchell: Abstraction and Analogy in AI

Melanie Mitchell: Abstraction and Analogy in AI

Author: Daniel Bashir December 15, 2022 Duration: 54:47

Have suggestions for future podcast guests (or other feedback)? Let us know here!

In episode 53 of The Gradient Podcast, Daniel Bashir speaks to Professor Melanie Mitchell.

Professor Mitchell is the Davis Professor at the Santa Fe Institute. Her research focuses on conceptual abstraction, analogy-making, and visual recognition in AI systems. She is the author or editor of six books and her work spans the fields of AI, cognitive science, and complex systems. Her latest book is Artificial Intelligence: A Guide for Thinking Humans

Subscribe to The Gradient Podcast:  Apple Podcasts  | Spotify | Pocket Casts | RSSFollow The Gradient on Twitter

Outline:

* (00:00) Intro

* (02:20) Melanie’s intro to AI

* (04:35) Melanie’s intellectual influences, AI debates over time

* (10:50) We don’t have the right metrics for empirical study in AI

* (15:00) Why AI is Harder than we Think: the four fallacies

* (20:50) Difficulties in understanding what’s difficult for machines vs humans

* (23:30) Roles for humanlike and non-humanlike intelligence

* (27:25) Whether “intelligence” is a useful word

* (31:55) Melanie’s thoughts on modern deep learning advances, brittleness

* (35:35) Abstraction, Analogies, and their role in AI

* (38:40) Concepts as analogical and what that means for cognition

* (41:25) Where does analogy bottom out

* (44:50) Cognitive science approaches to concepts

* (45:20) Understanding how to form and use concepts is one of the key problems in AI

* (46:10) Approaching abstraction and analogy, Melanie’s work / the Copycat architecture

* (49:50) Probabilistic program induction as a promising approach to intelligence

* (52:25) Melanie’s advice for aspiring AI researchers

* (54:40) Outro

Links:

* Melanie’s homepage and Twitter

* Papers

* Difficulties in AI, hype cycles

* Why AI is Harder than we think

* The Debate Over Understanding in AI’s Large Language Models

* What Does It Mean for AI to Understand?

* Abstraction, analogies, and reasoning

* Abstraction and Analogy-Making in Artificial Intelligence

* Evaluating understanding on conceptual abstraction benchmarks



Get full access to The Gradient at thegradientpub.substack.com/subscribe

Hosted by Daniel Bashir, The Gradient: Perspectives on AI moves beyond surface-level headlines to explore the intricate machinery and human ideas shaping artificial intelligence. Each episode is built on a foundation of deep research, leading to conversations that are both technically substantive and broadly accessible. You'll hear from researchers, engineers, and philosophers who are actively building and critiquing our technological future, discussing not just how AI systems work, but the larger implications of their integration into society. This isn't about speculative hype; it's a grounded examination of real progress, persistent challenges, and ethical considerations from those on the front lines. The discussions peel back layers on topics like model architecture, policy, and the fundamental science behind the algorithms becoming part of our daily lives. For anyone curious about the substance behind the buzz-whether you have a technical background or are simply keen to understand a defining technology of our age-this podcast offers a crucial and thoughtful resource. Tune in for a consistently detailed and nuanced take that treats artificial intelligence with the complexity it deserves.
Author: Language: English Episodes: 100

The Gradient: Perspectives on AI
Podcast Episodes
Judy Fan: Reverse Engineering the Human Cognitive Toolkit [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:32:39
Episode 136I spoke with Judy Fan about:* Our use of physical artifacts for sensemaking* Why cognitive tools can be a double-edged sword* Her approach to scientific inquiry and how that approach has developedEnjoy—and let…
L.M. Sacasas: The Questions Concerning Technology [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:47:20
Episode 135I spoke with L. M. Sacasas about:* His writing and intellectual influences* The value of asking hard questions about technology and our relationship to it* What happens when we decide to outsource skills and c…
Pete Wolfendale: The Revenge of Reason [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:52:57
Episode 134I spoke with Pete Wolfendale about:* The flaws in longtermist thinking* Selections from his new book, The Revenge of Reason* Metaphysics* What philosophy has to say about reason and AIEnjoy—and let me know wha…
Peter Lee: Computing Theory and Practice, and GPT-4's Impact [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:01:48
Episode 133I spoke with Peter Lee about:* His early work on compiler generation, metacircularity, and type theory* Paradoxical problems* GPT-4s impact, Microsoft’s “Sparks of AGI” paper, and responses and criticismEnjoy—…
Manuel & Lenore Blum: The Conscious Turing Machine [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:23:04
Episode 132I spoke with Manuel and Lenore Blum about:* Their early influences and mentors* The Conscious Turing Machine and what theoretical computer science can tell us about consciousnessEnjoy—and let me know what you…
Kevin Dorst: Against Irrationalist Narratives [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:15:21
Episode 131I spoke with Professor Kevin Dorst about:* Subjective Bayesianism and epistemology foundations* What happens when you’re uncertain about your evidence* Why it’s rational for people to polarize on political mat…
David Pfau: Manifold Factorization and AI for Science [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 2:00:52
Episode 130I spoke with David Pfau about:* Spectral learning and ML* Learning to disentangle manifolds and (projective) representation theory* Deep learning for computational quantum mechanics* Picking and pursuing resea…
Sergiy Nesterenko: Automating Circuit Board Design [not-audio_url] [/not-audio_url]

Duration: 1:03:35
Episode 128I spoke with Sergiy Nesterenko about:* Developing an automated system for designing PCBs* Difficulties in human and automated PCB design* Building a startup at the intersection of different areas of expertiseB…